Personal liability for breaches of employment standards

June 6, 2024

 

The director of a company and his wife, a manager, have recently been held liable to pay over $90,000 in reparations to an employee after the company breached minimum employment standards.


The employee worked for the company for just over 12 months. The company went into liquidation at the end of 2020, but the employee claimed that he had not been paid for many of the hours that he worked. The employee also claimed that he had not been paid his annual leave and public holiday entitlements.


Despite the company being in liquidation, the Employment Relations Authority was able to look into the issue as the director and manager of the company could be held personally liable for the breaches.


The Authority first had to determine whether the employee’s claims were accurate.


Evidence showed that the employer had failed to keep wage and time records. The director provided various reasons for this failure such as the device that kept the wage records had been stolen. The director did not provide sufficient evidence to support these reasons.


In any case, the Authority held that the employer had failed to keep accurate wage and time records, regardless of the reason. Keeping wage and time records is a legal requirement for employers in New Zealand and the director therefore breached minimum employment standards.


The director had also failed to pay the employee his annual leave and public holiday entitlements. This was accepted by the director.


The Authority ordered the company to pay the employee $29,990 in minimum wages, $10,240 in annual leave entitlements, $1,970 for work on public holidays and $1,720 for alternative holidays for public holidays worked.


However, the company had been liquidated and therefore could not pay the Authority’s orders. 


The Authority held that both the director and his wife could be held personally liable to pay the orders made against the company, because they were persons involved in the employment breaches.


As director of the company, the director had a strong influence over the operations of the company. Further, the wife had sufficient influence over the management and administration of the company in her role as manager. The employee had raised various issues with the wife as manager, which she had failed to address.


The director and manager were therefore ordered to personally pay the Authority’s orders against the company. The director was also ordered to pay a penalty of $20,000 for his involvement in the breaches, while his wife was ordered to pay a penalty of $10,000.



The director was also ordered to repay a $21,000 premium that had been paid by the employee.


It is important to be aware of minimum employment standards, both as an employee and an employer. This case emphasises that individuals can be held personally liable for breaches of employment standards.


If you are confused about these standards or believe you have been treated unfairly, it pays to seek advice from a professional with experience in the area.


Source: Rainey Collins May 2024

By Stuarts Accountants November 26, 2025
ENTERTAINMENT EXPENSE ITEMS A list of common travel and entertainment expense items and their tax treatment - Food and drink while out of town on business when eating alone or with other team members 100% deductible and no FBT - Food and drink while overseas on business eating with team members, customers, suppliers, prospects etc. 100% deductible and no FBT - Food and drink with customers, suppliers, prospects etc. either in or out of town on business 50% deductible and no FBT - Non-taxable meal allowances paid to employees working overtime 100% deductible and no FBT - Morning and afternoon teas 100% deductible and no FBT - Lunches and more than incidental food & beverages for employees 50% deductible and no FBT - Samples provided for advertising 100% deductible and no FBT - Food & beverages as part of training seminars, conferences, trade displays that are at least 4 consecutive hours 100% deductible and no FBT - Rugby, show, movie tickets etc. for staff and used when staff member chooses 100% deductible and subject to FBT* - Sporting, cultural or other recreational activities, e.g. golf or corporate box 50% deductible and no FBT - Hire of boat to entertain customers, suppliers, prospects etc. 50% deductible and no FBT - Friday night drinks, staff parties and other social functions (whether at the office or elsewhere) e.g. Christmas parties, reception for existing or potential customers, suppliers etc. This includes any supporting expenses i.e. transport (taxis), crockery hire, glasses, waiters, music, etc. 50% deductible and no FBT - Gift for client, employee, supplier etc. which contains food and drink 50% deductible and no FBT - Gift for client, excluding food and drink 100% deductible and no FBT - Gifts for employees (or spouse) 100% deductible and subject to FBT* - Gift for non employee who helped with job 100% deductible and no FBT - Gym membership for an employee paid by the employer 100% deductible and subject to FBT* - Vouchers (no GST claim as GST triggered when voucher used) 100% deductible and subject to FBT* * You are only subject to FBT if you are over the exemptions. These are $300 per quarter per employee, or $22,500 per annum for all employees. If you reach either of these in any period, you are required to pay FBT on the total amount. Note there is a $1,200 per employee per annum threshold if you are filing FBT on an annual basis. This list is designed to be an overview of the tax treatment of common entertainment expenses. If you have a question relating to this list, or you have another expense you would like clarification on, please contact us. GST is not claimable on 50% portion. 
By Stuarts Accountants August 19, 2025
Key Proposed Changes 1. “Specified Contractor” Gateway Test The Bill proposes a clearer test to distinguish independent contractors from employees. If all of the following criteria are met, a worker qualifies as a specified contractor, and is excluded from the legal definition of an "employee": 1. A written agreement specifies they are an independent contractor. 2. They are not restricted from working for others (except when engaged with the contracting party). 3. They are not required to work at specified times or days, or can subcontract their work (subject to vetting/statutory compliance). 4. The contract does not terminate if the contractor declines additional work. 5. The contractor had a reasonable opportunity to obtain independent advice before entering into the arrangement. Implications: This aims to increase business flexibility and clarity. Contractors who meet the test cannot challenge their status in the Employment Relations Authority or Courts. 2. Remedy Assessment in Personal Grievances The Bill would narrow remedies available in personal grievance cases if the employee is found to have: * Committed serious misconduct (no remedies available). * Contributed to the grievance situation (no reinstatement or compensation for hurt, humiliation, or loss of benefit; other remedies may still apply but can be reduced by up to 100%). * Additionally, adjudicators (Authority or Court) must consider whether the employee’s conduct impaired the employer’s ability to act fairly, and raise the bar for procedural error claims. 3. High-Income Threshold for Unjustified Dismissal Claims Employees earning over NZD 180,000 per annum (base salary only—excluding bonuses, allowances, commissions, overtime, superannuation) would not be eligible to raise personal grievances for unjustified dismissal —unless they explicitly opt in via their employment agreement. * Key details: * A 12-month transitional period will apply for existing employees (unless they opt in earlier). * The income threshold will automatically adjust annually based on average weekly earnings, which introduces complexity in ongoing compliance. 4. End of the “30-Day Rule” for Collective Agreements * The “30-day rule”—which required terms of a collective agreement to apply to new employees for their first 30 days before they could move to an individual agreement—is to be repealed. * Under the proposed change: * Employers would provide new employees with information about collective agreements and unions. * Employees can immediately choose to sign an Individual Employment Agreement (IEA), which may include a **90-day trial period** if agreed. Additional Context & Commentary * Intent and Government Rationale: The Bill is positioned by the Government as a means to enhance labour market flexibility, reduce compliance costs, boost business innovation, and rebalance employer-employee interests, particularly in the personal grievance sphere. * Current Status: As of July 2025, public submissions were open (closing 13 August 2025), and the Bill was advancing through the select committee and readings. * Notably, in June 2025 the Parliament rejected amendments proposing to delay commencement to June 2026, keeping an earlier timeline —perhaps December 2025—for enactment. Summary Table Key Change - Description & Effects “Specified Contractor” Test - Workers meeting five criteria are excluded from employee status—limiting legal challenges Remedy Restrictions - Serious misconduct or employee contribution reduces or eliminates remedies $180,000 Threshold - High-earning employees excluded from unfair dismissal claims unless they opt in Repeal of 30-Day Rule - Allows immediate use of IEAs and 90-day trials for new hires, bypassing collective terms What to Watch Next Select Committee Process: Ongoing debates, public submissions, and possible amendments. Threshold Adjustments: Details on how the automatic salary threshold updates will work. Implementation Timeline: While December 2025 is possible, it depends on the legislative process and Royal Assent.  Sources: [1]: https://www.bellgully.com/insights/the-employment-relations-amendment-bill-has-landed-and-it-has-the-potential-to-transform-employment-relations-in-new-zealand/?utm_source=chatgpt.com "The Employment Relations Amendment Bill has landed" [2]: https://www.dentons.co.nz/en/insights/articles/2025/june/19/employment-relations-amendment-bill-2025?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Employment Relations Amendment Bill 2025" [3]: https://www.laneneave.co.nz/news-events/era-four-key-changes/?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Explained: Employment Relations Amendment Bill" [4]: https://www.parliament.nz/en/pb/hansard-debates/rhr/combined/HansDeb_20250624_20250625_52?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Employment Relations (Pay Deductions for Partial Strikes) ..." [5]: https://knowledge.dlapiper.com/dlapiperknowledge/globalemploymentlatestdevelopments/2025/significant-amendments-to-the-employment-relations-act?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Significant amendments to the Employment Relations Act" [6]: https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=b905b99b-6503-4444-b0a3-be27a0d206fa&utm_source=chatgpt.com "Key insights into the new Employment Relations ..." [7]: https://www.parliament.nz/en/pb/sc/committees-press-releases/public-submissions-open-on-the-employment-relations-amendment-bill/?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Public submissions open on the Employment Relations ..." [8]: https://www.mbie.govt.nz/dmsdocument/30958-employment-relations-amendment-bill-2025-approval-for-introduction-proactiverelease-pdf?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Employment Relations Amendment Bill 2025: Approval for ..." [9]: https://www.humankind.nz/blog/an-update-on-employment-law-changes?utm_source=chatgpt.com "An update on employment law changes - Humankind NZ"
By Stuarts Accountants May 22, 2025
What is Income Protection Insurance? Your income is often your biggest asset and losing it can turn life upside down. If you’re unable to work—either temporarily or permanently—because you’re sick or injured, Income Protection Insurance will provide you with money to live on as a monthly payment while you’re not receiving your salary or wage. Income Protection Insurance benefits: Income support Pays you a monthly benefit if you’re unable to work because of illness or injury Rehabilitation & retraining support Helps you with your rehabilitation and retraining costs Recurrent disability Pays you a monthly benefit if you suffer the same sickness or disability within a year Return to work Pays you a bonus benefit if you are able to return to work Family assist We’ll pay for a nurse or family member to look after you at home for up to 6 months Accommodation support Pays for your family to be with you if they live more than 100km away Disability reset Allows you to claim again if you suffer a related sickness or injury Elective surgery Pays you a monthly benefit if you are disabled due to an elective surgery Payment while overseas Pays you a monthly benefit if you are disabled while overseas Funeral assistance We reimburse your family up to three times the monthly benefit for your funeral costs if you die Grief support Helps with the cost of professional grief support to cope with sudden changes Overseas assist Reimburse you and one support person for travel back to New Zealand if disabled overseas New parent premium waiver We’ll pay your premiums for six months while you’re on parental leave Ref: Asteron Life